Skip to main content

Google home vs Amazon echo - a comparative study through Indian perspective

The home speakers hit the Indian market on April 10 and as that of echo devices hit the market much before on October, 2017. It's been 6 months since Google home has become part of many families in India, even before its launch I was using home mini but was not able to use all its features and was eagerly waiting for an official release. Now, for quite a time I have been acquainted with both Alexa as well as Google home, and it's a perfect time to check where the two kindred virtual spirits lie with respect to the Indian market.

Google home devices


Alexa already had a head start of 4 months and on top of that was well configured for the Indian market right from the beginning. On the other hand, when home released the only thing that changed was that I was able to choose my default music provided from 2 more options - saavn and gaana, rest it was all the same as before. Though Google enthusiasts (me being one too) were quite confident about home getting all the features like US or UK pretty soon, but I must say even after six months the disappointment is not gone completely. Earlier, Alexa was pretty much able to call a cab, order food, crack some Indian jokes, catch up some Indian phrases specially in case of Hindi songs, but all that Google was able to do was play songs. Google was much behind Alexa in terms of the Indian sector.

 Amazon echo devices

But the same lag still persists even after six months is a bit difficult to admit. Google did update itself on quite a number of things like now it can book a cab. People feel comfortable with people of same accent between them which Alexa provides, Google's American accent makes it feel like an outsider. This is were Alexa gets a boost. Moreover, Google also does not provide support of Indian news channels which makes it a big NO for staying up-to-date with news from Indian perspective. Recently, I checked and Google is able to accept my request to book an Uber but failed to execute it as she claimed that "service is not available to the destination" whereas it is available from their app, I don't want to get into this contradiction but it's good to see this feature finally getting into Google. Another thing that Google got better at is catching Indian phrases of Hindi, Bengali, and regional songs but it still got to be better. It still has a lot of things to work on compared to Alexa mainly the problem of accent.

Google is working on to update it to match the needs of Indian market but it better be fast because the head start of Alexa is increasing day-by-day. Seeing the progress and updates of Google in US as well as other countries, we can hope for the best to come soon to India.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Indian Constitution: the unfulfilled dream

 As we celebrated the ‘Constitution day’ on 26th November, bragging about being the world’s largest democracy, the question we failed to ask ourselves is whether we have truly lived up to the essence of our constitution. The Constituent Assembly of India had adopted the Constitution on this day in 1949, and the current government decided in 2015 to observe this day annually as the Constitution Day. Our Constitution declares India to be a “sovereign, socialist, secular, democratic republic and to secure to all its citizens justice, social, economic and political; liberty of thought, expression, belief, faith, and worship; equality of status and of opportunity; and to promote among them all fraternity assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity and integrity of the nation”. Even though our constitution offers so much, the printed media has repeatedly pointed out the inability to uphold them. To quote Granville Austin from his book, Working a Democratic Constitution, the constitu

Expectation

Expectations. The world drives around that single word. An investor expects the market to return profits, a student expects good grades, Hollywood expects every Indian to greet with namaste , etc. All of us expect something from someone or something. Expectations are what keeps us going. People during the agricultural revolution did not expect to leave Earth, but now we expect that someday we will step on Mars.  The question is: Is expectation worth it? The answer is 'depends' on what you are expecting, whether it is within the jurisdiction of possibility or not. 'Possibility', this again has a relative definition. Now the question comes, how do we know whether it is possible? Well, that can be answered only by the questioner. We expect a lot of things, we get hurt but again we keep on expecting. The worthiness of expectations can be connoted  only when we are successful in achieving it.  I am not making any sense, am I? Well, scroll up! Let's see if I can tur

The Japanaese Renaissance

Whenever we think of Japan, we think of Hiroshima and Nagasaki. The Second World War had left Japan completely devastated, depleted of its teeming potential and resources. After 74 years, Japan has metamorphosed into a world power, flaunting its suave in multilateral fields.With t he excitement of the Tokyo 2020 Olympics all around and shops ready with official merchandise, Japan is pushing the accelerator on full throttle to showcase their best.  My recent visit to Japan was worthwhile, a revelation in itself. The rapid development of Japan never fails to awestruck anyone. The main shifting point was during the Meiji dynasty - during which Japan faced a huge technological, political, and educational influx from the western nations and broke out of their isolated cocoon. Since then, Japan has no turning back. The disciplined traditional nature of the people along with their quality education have contributed a lot to this development. Recently, the Japan government has decided to